Showing posts with label The basics of philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The basics of philosophy. Show all posts

Saturday, 24 June 2017

The basics of ... Reality and perception.

Hi.

It's been a while since I managed to get my nose back into Nigel Warburtons book, all about The basics of philosophy. 

I had a spare quiet sunny afternoon (or at least I think I did ) so I made a cuppa, and sat down to go through the next chapter, one I have been looking forward to for some time.

Appearance, Reality and Perception. 

How do we know something is real? How do we know it is not? How do we know what reality IS?
How do we know things? How do we know we know?

I know it's Saturday afternoon, and I'm sat at my desk and typing this article. I also know that if I move my chair will squeak.

I know it's Saturday because I checked the calendar. I know I'm sat here because my brain tells me through all my senses that I'm doing so, and I know that my chair will squeak because  I've experienced it doing so and remember that fact.

Or do I? what I actually have in all three cases are perceptions. How many times have you thought it was Saturday only to realise it wasn't.. and you've looked at the information wrongly? My brain could well be dreaming that I'm sat here.. and thus my perceptions of my activity is skewed. Plus, we all "know" memory isn't infallible...

So is "reality" simply a set of electrical signals, current or historical, interpreted by the brain?

Philosophers frame these arguments under a number of headings.

Common sense realism

In essence the simplest and most often seen "lay persons" interpretation of  perception. Things exist and we see them as they are, as a result of their existence. An objects existence does not depend on its being observed, thus if a tree falls in the woods and no one observes it fall, then the tree both exists and falls.

Representative realism

This is an extension of the common sense position whereby it takes into account the idea that what we "see" is merely a representation of the object, not the object itself. For example a stick in water that appears bent but isn't, or a hot road appearing to shimmer when in fact it isn't moving. This also takes into account differences in the viewers. For example if two people observe a dress, one person may see a blue dress, but the other being colour blind, may not. Thus "blue" isn't a mechanism or quality of the dress, but rather of the mechanism of its perception.

Idealism

This is again an extension of relative realism. Since all we "know" is based on internal representation of the outside world, one cannot prove the existence of the outside world since all proof would be via  the means of our own sense, and thus merely representative. This theory also leads to the idea that physical things only exist when being perceived. So our tree would not only fail to fall if no one were to see it, but would also fail to exist.

Phenomenalism 

John Stuart Mill was a phenomenalist. This is again an extension of the idealism theory, yet it argues that unobserved objects can exist since it is "possible" to observe them. Although it accounts for  the existance of unobserved objects in this way it still postulates that all experiences of our external world is indirect, via internal representations.

Causal realism

This would be one that the scientific amongst you would probably like the most since it takes the view that the purpose of perception is to navigate our external world therefore our external world must exist. (A philosophical argument for "evolution" or the "design argument" perhaps?) Our external environment has certain qualities that over time we as beings have become attuned to recognising and navigating through and around. It does reduce all perception to merely information gathering, but it remains at time of writing the most satisfactory account of perception. It differs from the common sense argument above in that it allows for those errors or shifts in perception and doesn't assume that what is being perceived is actually always "truth" in the same way.

Head hurting yet? or do you just think it is? 

So, what we really have here is a chicken and egg scenario. Every one of us can only perceive our external environment through our senses. They are the means by which we determine the world around us, and we can never view the world but through them. (Think of it as akin to being locked in a cinema, with the screen and speakers the only window the outside world)

Do we know what we don't know yet? 

Hundreds of years ago, due to lack of astrological knowledge, people would perhaps take things at "face value" The moon for instance, getting bigger through the seasons or when near the horizon, would probably be believed to actually "be" bigger, since there was no knowledge base to refute that argument and people could see that it certainly "looked bigger"

Here we have the paradox. It is only through what we "know" that we can question the "unknown". We now "know" about the moon, its orbit and the reasons why it appears larger or smaller. We "know" it doesn't actually change its physical size. But that knowledge has been acquired through the use of human senses and thus is open to interpretation. With that comes the realisation that those interpretations may be inaccurate.

If you've ever seen the film inception, you'll get the idea of a dream within a dream, or perhaps the matrix where humans are all living in a VR world of computer generation. Those might be extreme version of the hypothesis that everything we perceive might not actually be as it is. But they are perfect illustrations of that concept.

Of course if you'll indulge me in a little conjecture here in stretching things beyond the bounds of pure theory,  if one brings in another human quality - "emotion"- things can change once more. Why? well much like the colour blind example above it has more to do with the observer than the observed. How we perceive things is one question, how we interpret that perception is another, but they are of course linked

It's why certain songs will raise a smile or a tear, and certain words mean many many different things to different people. 

The songs don't change, but our perceptions of them and the meaning ascribed to them does. So, since everything we observe changes us, does that mean we can never observe the same thing twice in exactly the same way? Since we are never the same having observed it the first time?

Yeah, sure you're welcome, that conundrumn might keep ya awake at night.. assuming you're actually not already asleep that is..

But the point of that segway into emotion is to highlight that were there only a screen and the outside world "not real", then one would be heading toward solipsism, or a view that only one's own mind exists and is real. In which case why do we have emotion? Emotion exists to enable us to interact with others, ergo it's an evolutionary mechanism the existence of which proves the existence of others.

Any how verbose verbiage and vexatious vagaries of language aside, that's it in a nutshell. Reality is something we only ever perceive and thus we cannot be sure it is reality at all since the scientific method would be to observe it via two independent routes, which of course we cannot do.

What we can do however is to observe two or three variation of phenomena to prove or disprove theories around reality and our world at large.

But that I'll leave for the next chapter in Nigel's book, which happily enough is all about Science...

Sweet dreams!

Sarah

Tuesday, 9 May 2017

The basics of...Politics.

Hey.

I thought it was high time I revisited my mini series on the the book by Nigel Warburton. "The basics of Philosophy"

In this case: Politics.

I have taken a while to write this compared to the other two or three articles I've done from reading Nigel's book. That's because I've been watching. The UK and US political arena's are currently very very ... interesting. So I've been watching and thinking about the points made by Nigel in his book.

Dependent on your POV The US Republican & UK Conservative Party policy's are either "get stuff done& cut the beuracratic BS" or becoming "scarily autocratic" regimes. TBH It's most likely that people are somewhere on that scale, liking some stuff and disliking other bits.

We are just over 100 days into the current POTUS tenure and now heading into a UK election. To say the situation is volatile and unpredictable is ....imo putting it mildly.

Unlike the previous articles where I go into huge detail on the terminology and sections of Nigel's book, I'm not going to do that here. But if you want to do some further reading, look at these concepts.

  • Equality: Why? between whom? and with reference to what exactly?
  • Democracy: Direct or Representative? Does voting work? is democracy an illusion?
  • Freedom: What does this mean? how is it limited and why so? Negative freedoms?

So here is a potted guide to philosophical politics, or the philosophy of political debate, and also my thoughts on where were are at currently in the UK and US.

The basics of: Politics.

Ask anyone what the "goal" of politics is, and you might get a number of answers. It depends on precisely who's goal we are talking about. The people or the decision makers? Are they in fact the same? How do we know? Let's say we broadly mean "Society". What is the goal of politics in society? What is its purpose?

To answer that, consider what happens when politics fails. Politics "is" the art of talking, discussion and crucially, of making decisions, deals and producing outcomes. Those decisions should be - and mostly are - justified on the basis of being "in the best interests of...." and theoretically at least are reached via compromise, and mutual benefit.

So if we accept that view of politics, when this process fails the alternative is what?  Insular and very protective arguments, lack of progression, frustration, removal of common purpose or its recognition, and ultimately if unchecked, war.

Tiny, Small, Medium, big, ....Biggest....

The neighbours fighting over a tree that is blocking light to one of the windows. Cats digging in next doors flower beds. The price of oil on the stock market if bought in bulk. Trade agreements, national boundaries, fishing quotas, even sovereignty. All these examples can and do have an element of political negotiation involved in their process at some level.

So politics can be thought of as negotiation for mutual benefit and thus reward, the societal goal of which is "Peace", or at the very least the "absence of war", which is not quite the same thing.

The Athenians had a very rudimentary political system where anyone could spend a day on the council for decisions. However one man who observed this was .. yes you guessed it... Socrates. He observed two things.

1) Too many people with differing needs results in no decision.
2) Those on the council for the day often didn't really know anything about the things they were to decide on, thus often made the wrong decision.

As a result society eventually comes up with a compromise. An elected representative political system. The "many" actively select "a few" to represent their interests. However this has a few holes and problems as we shall see.

So this is what we call "representative democracy". Something pretty close to what most countries run on today.

But what of the individual living in society? Sure the "absence of war" is to be applauded but there are other simple needs. Food, shelter, work and/or employment, health care, law, order and safety. There are moments in the life of a democratic system where these mean differing things to differing people, for reasons of their own morality..

For example in the present day US we have the recent legislation for same sex marriages. And the resultant religious freedom bills that have been put in place to either "protect" religious liberty and ideology, or "circumvent non discrimination legislation" dependent on ones POV. Both of these legislations are supposedly conceived via the proposers sincerely held moral and ethical judgments & beliefs, yet they are diametrically opposed, even mutually exclusive.

So what do we do here? who is right? and really, is there actually a wrong?  With that in mind, It's not hard to see why Politics is so problematic for society.

It really comes down to just two words.

"Interests" 
and 
"morality"

Both can be "societal" or 'personal" concepts., and in each case their erroneous application causes problems:

Church and state

In the US currently one has to admit that there is a close relationship between religion and state.  There is however a constitutional and legal framework for how these two institutions should be kept a reasonable distance from each other.

But why is this important? There is much talk of the first amendment and the constitutional "separation of church and state" in the US, by which one usually means the "Christian" church. However this is often miss interpreted. What is actually written suggests that congress shall:

"....make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances."

The grounds for argument here is clear.

Let's say you fundamentally believe that "marriage" is between a Man and Woman (leaving aside the definitions of each for now...) Well then the constitution should not permit the passing of laws limiting your free exercise of that belief if it stems from religious conviction.  So if you as a cake shop owners choose not to bake a cake for a wedding between two women? ....is that ok?

 If its a"moral" viewpoint born of religion it may indeed be protected. However, what do we mean by "free exercise" exactly, and to whom does that apply? Furthermore,  if you take the parts of Christian teaching that talk of "an eye for and eye" etc, and apply the same logic, can the government therefore legally prevent religious honour killings?

One cannot of course condone honour killings, and nor could we rationally argue that they be legally sanctioned. However it follows from this that if they cannot be allowed, then the cake shop owner is on dodgy ground, since the underlaying premise for each argument is the same? (freedom of religious convictions) This is why the first amendment needs to be looked at in conjunction with other laws to ascertain which of them takes precedent in a given set of circumstance. Why can't we condone honour killings? because it's murder... pretty obvious... In the case of cakes, anti discrimination legislature took precedent, via the 9th amendment:

“The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.”

in essence .. "its not about cake" or "water fountains".

It's about people, and how we interact with them. One cannot suggest that "my right" to "A" is greater than "your right" to "B" if by carrying out "A" distress or harm is caused and "B" happens to be a protected right under the 9th amendment.

Now consider the other view point. You're "for" same sex marriage. So if the government sided with the religious arguments in favour of a fixed definition of marriage, could it be said to be forcing people to conform to a religious view point ..? I suppose one would perhaps have to oblige them to marry to actually make that argument..but tis food for thought. It certainly would be awkward to explain that away in respect of the 9th amendment.

And of course we can ask in this context what is a "religion" exactly?  One could interpret one's sexuality as a religion in the legal sense here, thus the government cannot block the free exercise of that? ... Of course that just becomes a can of worms, & I am deliberately stretching the point....... Jedi anyone?

I jest but you get the idea. Things are rarely clear cut. As a result it is abundantly clear that pure theological arguments of morality are not best suited to use in legal and societal terms. (unless you'd like to go back to loosing hand if accused of stealing of course?) Rule by religious theocracy is by definition exclusionary of anyone not sharing of it's founding beliefs and/or principles.

That is not to say the holding of theological beliefs is wrong. It is the application of them in a legal sense that is problematic. Which is why there must be clear boundaries between the theological and the judicial. An individual citizen in the US has the right to choose their religious belief. They do not however, have an opt out of the legislative process.

Trump's "white" House. Who's ethics are they, and in who's interest?

Yet, as I look at the US, it would seem that a fledgling theorcracy is what is being proposed. There are a high proportion of old school Christian white middle Americans with a certain world view that are populating the corridors of power at present. The rule of law, with properly seperated secular judicial review is slowly being supplanted by moral and ethical judgements based in theological tradition, which are then erroneously passed off as legal expertise & packaged as in the best interests of all, when in fact this is not the case.

Err no Jeff..Sorry...

Traditional party lines seem to have been somewhat circumvented by the need to be White, male and "Christian" in the fundamental sense. Tis a view that sits well with the die hard separatists and those who fervently preach and believe that America belongs to "the white race". (whatever that is) whilst still going to church on Sunday. I have to wonder, will we look back at this time in history as a "knee jerk" to having had a black president? The flurry of orders that came from the pen of Trump seemed at one time to have no purpose other than to eradicate the name of Obama from the legal statute. The only way they made sense was through the lens of a white supremacist cleansing operation.

Of course there are practicing devout christians who are not of this ilk. Some may even disagree with the principles mentioned here in. Thats ok. No one is wanting to outlaw disagreement...(yet) But wilfully discriminating against your fellow human on the sure and certain belief that you're inconvertibly right? That's a whole other ball game right there, and thankfully ACLU et al seem to be doing a nice job of defending those who otherwise would have no means of reparation.

Needless to say all of this worries me. Theocracies are known for being less than forthcoming in the art of political compromise and discourse, suspicious of science and independent thought. Discouraging of education, and controlling of the public access to it, they are based on fundamental beliefs that are often mutually exclusive of competing theocracies, relying very much on the un swerving doctrine of controlled teachings.... otherwise people might start to believe the "bad hombres", or that dinosaurs actually did exist and that the earth actually rotates around the sun.



None of this bodes well for America, or the world. And whilst a country and it's government is bigger than it's "personality" figure heads..."The Trump" as a climate change denier, and his VP as an evolution sceptic, are fully paid up members of that white christian fundamentalist mostly male club. A scary "theory" indeed and the biggest single challenge facing the American political system in decades.

Watch this space.

But what of the UK?

I'll get to that, but I'll save it for next time...

Sarah ;-)

Part two

Monday, 10 April 2017

The basics of - Morality & Ethics part 3

Recently I've been pondering a thought.

Is "vested interest" and what is deemed "appropriate" replacing the human progression towards "universal good"?

Universal good in this context being, opportunity, parity, education, prospects, happiness, and the access to sufficient means to provide for ones self and ones family.

It kinda ties into the 3rd part of my philosophical mini series:

Applied Ethics.

Consider the theatre of politics. Very often lobby groups will push their agenda and may, via quiet meetings with various people, agree to support certain other agenda's or goals - IF their own needs are met. This in essence is the very spirit of collaborative working and compromise, but the driver, or "maxim" to use Kant's expression, is merely a vested interest in a certain type of outcome.

Arguably an immoral use of a system.

BUT if that lobby group happens to be trans rights, or funding for pre natal hospital care, or women's access to health care, or ACLU, the Gun lobby, Oil industry, even evangelical groups etc, then people will make various decisions regarding the morality of the lobbying process based on the cause that is being lobbied for.

Me for instance, I'd suggest trans rights would be a "good cause" but judging by the comments section in the lower third of the internet, I'm sure many would disagree. The reasoning behind a decision as to the morality of a given goal or methodology could be the application of the consequential, or maybe duty bound theories.

For example I believe it (trans rights) an ethical cause because the outcome of success would see an improvement in peoples lives, and improvement in their access to the universal goods listed above. An opponent might disagree on religious or scientific grounds, since they subscribe to a view that the concept of "trans" isn't a legitimate way of being and thus to promote it is ethically wrong, since its harmful in wider sense, regardless of the consequences of such a view point to a given indivudal.

Of course I am trans. ( Or, if your an opponent of that concept, you would have to accept that I at least believe myself thus, even were you to disagree) So does that place me in the the vested interest category? You betcha it does. Does that undermine my arguments? No, only my perceived (and actual) impartiality.

That issue of impartiality is the central reason for my preference to look at the trans issue through the lens of anthropological and philosophical thought, rather than the reverse, which is to perceive everything in life through the lens of my vested interest in the trans question. If (some of) the arguments made by the trans community on its own behalf cannot stand up to structured critical scrutiny, they are thus proven as bad arguments. That fact doesn't change, regardless of how I feel about the underlying wider context.

It's small though signiifcant effort on my part to "balance the books" as it were.

Back in my nursing days I often considered the use of the word "appropriate" in the medical context. Seldom would you hear  "right", "wrong" or "good" "bad" used in the context of an action pertaining to a patients care.

The "most appropriate treatment" was the universal phrase.

Yet this, like many things is open to interpretation. Appropriate for whom? The establishment? The patient? The family? The wider society?

This "appropriate argument" is raging in America at the present with regard to not just trans issues, but a whole swathe of the population for whom it is deemed "inappropriate" by some to provide the basics of what we in the UK have come to expect of a healthcare system.

The ACA was America's first foray for many years into addressing its healthcare access disparity. Yet still some people wanted to pull it down, presumably for their own vested interests rather than the common of access to a universal good. (health)

After all, History will record that it was postulated and set up by a black guy. Certain sections of  todays America simply won't stand for that. Nor the idea that "an underserving poor" can access health care that "they pay for". Both premises are of course open to fairly stringent rebuttal, yet  a significant number of people still cling to these types of "moral" viewpoints.

I read recently of the case of a poorly baby girl. Again this is in America. She was denied treatment for a minor, yet potentially serious condition. One easily sorted within todays modern medical world.

The reason for the denial of health care to this infant? Her parents were Lesbian and the Dr objected to treatment on the basis of religious moral objection to the parental lifestyle.

Consider the hypocratic oath: written by Hippocrates, in ancient greek times, circa 300BC (damn those clever greeks again!) A modern version of which is shown below:

I swear to fulfill, to the best of my ability and judgment, this covenant:
I will respect the hard-won scientific gains of those physicians in whose steps I walk, and gladly share such knowledge as is mine with those who are to follow.
I will apply, for the benefit of the sick, all measures which are required, avoiding those twin traps of overtreatment and therapeutic nihilism.
I will remember that there is art to medicine as well as science, and that warmth, sympathy, and understanding may outweigh the surgeon's knife or the chemist's drug.
I will not be ashamed to say "I know not," nor will I fail to call in my colleagues when the skills of another are needed for a patient's recovery.
I will respect the privacy of my patients, for their problems are not disclosed to me that the world may know. Most especially must I tread with care in matters of life and death. If it is given me to save a life, all thanks. But it may also be within my power to take a life; this awesome responsibility must be faced with great humbleness and awareness of my own frailty. Above all, I must not play at God.
I will remember that I do not treat a fever chart, a cancerous growth, but a sick human being, whose illness may affect the person's family and economic stability. My responsibility includes these related problems, if I am to care adequately for the sick.
I will prevent disease whenever I can, for prevention is preferable to cure.
I will remember that I remain a member of society, with special obligations to all my fellow human beings, those sound of mind and body as well as the infirm.
If I do not violate this oath, may I enjoy life and art, respected while I live and remembered with affection thereafter. May I always act so as to preserve the finest traditions of my calling and may I long experience the joy of healing those who seek my help.
Consider those lines of the text in bold. The doctor in question cited "religious objections". Not to the treatment, but to the actions of a family member of the patient. 

Religious/ethical exceptions do apply in the UK and US. To cases of abortion for example. However the essential difference here is that in the case of abortion, medical personnel object to the action and/or proceedure they are being asked to perform, and not an extraneous factor that is irrelevant to the treatment of the patient. 

Duty based theories of right and wrong, such as those derived via a literal interpretation of some of the Christian teachings, would suggest this Dr "may" have a case. However, those same arguments would preclude her from treating people who are Bisexual, polyamorous, or eat shell fish and wear mixed fibre cloth. (Leviticus) Thus it would seem theres an inherent objection present and the  religious argument is brought out when convenient. Where have heard that before? 

Furthermore in taking the hippocratic oath, or subscribing to the broader tenant of it meaning, by virtue of being a Doctor, there is an expectation to put aside personal and moral view points and act "in the interest of the patient" at all times. Clearly the Doctor is in breach of that specific and central premise of being a healer of others. 

Is she therefore demonstrating a fitness of judgment sufficient to the work of a Doctor? You decide. 

It raises an interesting point however. The separation between church and state. Or moreover Church and legislature. Something the USA is again currently wrestling with. Religion is a duty based theory or morality and ethical out come. It presupposes right and wrong actions as prescribed via it's teachings and disregards the outcome of those actions. Law is utilitarian, derived from a branch of consequential theory. Creating either the greatest "happiness" or the least "sadness" for people via prior examination of the potential outcomes of any decision.

It doesn't take much to deduce that the two are in many ways mutually exclusive.

So Applied Ethics is a minefield. Since the answer one gets or seeks, in response to ethical questions depends almost entirely on which ethical model one uses to frame those questions. The unscrupulous will use one or other ethical model to justify their actions in rebuttal of condemnation from those who see things differently.

Philosophers are generally agreed that the existence of human nature is a contentious concept, since it would contravene the free will argument and thus responsibility for our own actions.  But, given all the above, and the contradictory outcomes inherent to differing views of what it means to be/do good or bad, it it puts me in mind of Moral Relativism.

The first law of Einstein's theory of relatively suggested that "everything will be measured in relation to Something else"

And so it is with Ethics. judgments cannot exist in a vacuum. They must be compared to something, be it history, or examples of another viewpoint.  To say Morality is relative, in as much as it shifts with time and perception, is true enough. After all what was once viewed as immoral is now not, and what was once viewed as moral is not now so. The two major examples in recent times being homosexuality and Slavery. Of course there are some who still condemn homosexuality on the basis of they preferred moral framework, yet that stance carries all the legitimacy of an opinion, if not backed up by reason.

So, to conclude my mini series on ethics and the morality of actions, thoughts and intent. I will once again revisit a paraphrasing of the words of Dr John Corivino, for I cannot put it any better. (I hope he will forgive me the small change)

---------------------------

I'm not suggesting to you "don't make moral judgements",
I'm asking to make sure you have reasons for the moral judgements that you make. 
To put yourself in someone else shoes, before you judge them. 
Not to Judge someone on how they live and love, but on whether they Live and love.

----------------------------

Sarah.

The basics of - Morality and Ethics part 2

Hi,

Welcome to the second instalment of "part 2" in this series where i write about "the basics of philosophy by Nigel Warburton"

I part 1 we discussed questions surrounding the various versions of God.

In the first instalment of the part 2 about Ethics i discussed a few of the theories that define what may or may not be considered "Moral", or "Ethical" actions.

Here in the second instalment we take  look at Meta Ethics. thats is the study of theories about those central theories, and applications of them

In his book Nigel looks at Naturalism, Relativism, and Emotivism. A brief discussion of these will bring into focus some of the  things that the  first order theories of duty, consequentialism and Virtue cannot fully explore.

Naturalism.

In essence a theory that postulates formations of value based ethical judgments following on from directly discoverable scientific facts. Born from utilitarianism, and a  description of human nature, which leads to how we ought to behave. At it's core it presupposes a biological or naturally occurring reason for things to be as they are and moral judgements  as to what to do about that knowledge follow from that.

Problems with naturalism.

How can one link facts to value based judgments? One does not directly lead to the other, in a  relevant and quantitative  sense, except via the  method of opinion.

It may be a fact that I am fat for instance. Some might see that as inherent proof of my laziness, or perhaps a suggestion of an injury that precludes sufficient exercise. Both of these  are born of opinion and do not directly link to the  fact that i am fat.

So, ought we to make these  judgments of fat people based on our own perceptions of  them? David Hulme first raised this objection to naturalism by demonstrating that philosophers move, as i have done here, towards  "what we ought to do" from "what is", without further discussion.

To link this to a real world question. Arguments as to the causality of trans gender, or homosexuality. Both exist in the realm of science. Or to put it another way, discoverable biological or physiological fact. The Naturalist would argue therefore that the value placed on homosexuality and or transgender issues does directly follow from thees arguments, where as the anti naturist would suggest further debate is needed.

It's kinda like the "I was born this way, therefore it's natural, therefore its ok" argument.

On the surface this seems fine. But what of other traits that we are born with? Aggression, intolerance, integrity, or lack thereof? Just because we are born with traits doesn't mean we "ought to" act on them. Thus the presence of scientific knowledge regarding causality and reasoning about how homosexuality, transgender or any other trait to exist will not tell us what to do about it.

Questions surrounding human nature also play into this argument. Since if Human nature is given too much credence then it presupposes a somewhat passenger like life for humans. It diminishes "free will" and thus our responsibility for our own actions. How far each of these opposing arguments, "human nature" and "free will" play into each other becomes a matter for debate as too much emphasis on human nature leads us to devolve ourselves from responsibility for our failings at the species level. Its an interesting question when one considers the field of anthropology. Looking at humans as animals, subject to the same evolutionary forces that others on this planet live under. Animals is discussed in the next chapter... so i'll revisit this.

Relativism. 

Consider two areas of the world. Saudi Arabia and the UK. the laws in each country for the basis of their moral structure for ma societal POV. Yet one can be killed in Saudi, for committing an offence that in the UK would not even be considered so.

This is "moral relativism". The theory that different societies have differing views fright and wrong and thus an individuals perception of right and wrong is dependent on one's society. Which as we know is an accident of birth.

So..are ideas of "right" and "wrong" therefore definitive or subjective?

Consider the historical context as well as geographical. Years ago slavery was acceptable and not so long ago homosexuality was illegal in Britain. The case of Allan Turing, the father of modern computing and robotics remains a great moral question. His story was made into film, starring Benedict Cumberbatch, If you haven't seen "The imitation game" I heartily recommend it.

Two criticism of the relativism argument are firstly that "all morals are relative but relativism is true" which is almost animal farmesque in its complicit contradiction, and secondly that "what defines a society" is open to interpretation since it need not be a legal or country based definition.

This is highlighted by the case of Marine A. Sgt Blackman, killed a wounded Taliban fighter in Afghanistan and was subsequently tried and convicted of murder in a uk courts marshal. Recently the murder conviction was ruled unsafe on evidence of mental health considerations. The moral relativism here are that one can arguably say Soldiers or the military are their own society since they do have a different moral code to the average civilian, specifically to use the christian phrasing, "thou shall not kill".

The situational issues of where Sgt Blackman was also bear thought. It certainly wasn't what we in the peaceful west might call an "ordinary societal construct".  Thus can we reasonably suggest that ordinary societal rules should apply? Then their are the legal issues. The relative legality of "when" the afghan man was shot, not whether. Arguably it wasn't murder that Sgt Blackman was convicted of, rather it was "unsanctioned" murder, by virtue of the legal change inherent over those few minutes. Had the afghan man died by virtue of an exchange of fire, he would still have been "murdered" in the philosophical sense of one human killing and other deliberately, but it would have been legal and therefore by extension relatively morally justified for the POV of UK forces. Though not so by the afghan side. There are many other arguments in the case of Sgt Blackman, but this gives a flavour of the contradictory and relative nature of morality and legality based on situation.

Emotivism


"homosexuality is wrong"
Torture wrong"
"telling a lie is wrong"
"going against gods will is wrong"

Emotivism would suggest all these statements above, which are ethical statements of position, are meaningless. That is to say that in and of themselves they give not facts, only opinions. And as such should be accorded the same level of legitimacy. 

This it perhaps a weird one to get ones head around. exact when one asks the  question "why" of any of these statements. In doing so and opening the debate we then move from statement of opinion into discussion of reason why, factual or conceptual arguments as to evidence or moral theory. Thus Whilst once can quite easily see that bare statements have limited intrinsic value, the value of exploration of these statements cannot be understated. 

The major criticism of Emotivism is that it reduces significant and very weighty matters to mere triviality. If we simply decided that the statement "torture is wrong' was a matter of personal choice, it's not hard to see the consequences for society as whole. 

So there you have it. Three "meta ethical"theories of what "right" and "wrong" might mean. Theories that lean on the 1st level descriptions of ethical thought and attempt to further define Societal Ethical questions. In a sense, one can think of the first order theories being concerned with the individual relating to the world, and the second order meta ethical ones taking a broader societal view. One of humans examining how we deal en mass with societal ethical questions rather than individual ones. 

Of course theres over lap, and the boundaries are never clear, but hey, that's philosophy for ya...you want facts, try science! It's down the hall third door on the left! 



Tata! 

part three on applied ethical questions is found here! 

Sarah

Wednesday, 5 April 2017

So, "The basics of" - Morality & Ethics part 1

Hello all you lovely people of the world.

It has been a while since the first part of my discussion of "The basics of philosophy" by Nigel Warburton, In writing this the second instalment, looking at right and wrong, I've decided to split the subject into 3 parts.

1) Theoretical models of morality
2) Meta Ethics
3) Application

Otherwise you would need about 6 hours to read a massive amount of text in one single blog entry that probably wouldn't do the subject justice and would very likely leave you with square eyes and a scrambled brain!

Regular readers will have noted a pervasive thread of ethical discourse in my recent blogs, and obviously that's because all my thoughts about the application of these concepts inevitably seep into other writings when trying to make any given point. Also just in case you were wondering, the terms "Ethical" and "Moral" are often used interchangeably. Ethics is the study of that which makes things right or wrong, and is also occasionally called "Moral philosophy".

So, to recap and clarify some the ethical models that I have referenced in recent Articles

Duty based theories:

i Christian -judaeo tradition ethics

Religious views of morality are by design dependent on the teachings of the religion in question. Most - though not all - religions suggest an all powerful creator being. That being's will is said to be supremely good, therefore by extension anything deemed as "good" by that being must be morally and ethically sound.

This argument has two defining elements:

Firstly, It presupposes the existence of the supreme being which as you'll have seen in my first article in this series is itself open to philosophical question and scrutiny.

Secondly this approach is suggestive that actions are either "good" or "bad" irrespective of the consequences of those actions.

Religious deity based morality also invites the question, "Is what a deity defines as good actually good because they say it to be so, or do they say it is so, merely because a given action is already good?"

Dependent on ones point of view on this last question, It can lead to a some very odd actions being deemed to be "moral" or conversely it reduces the "all powerful deity" to a being subject to a higher power, that of predetermined and separate laws of ethical and unethical action.

ii Kantian ethics

Emmanuel Kant took a view that it was ones duty to act in a moral way. He posed the question "what is a moral action?" As a result he devised things called Maxims, which he defined as the "thought behind the action" what we today might call a motivation. Crucially Kant devolved this process from any emotional input. It is a purely rational thought mechanism.

This is useful since it can distinguish between identical actions that have very different maxim's and thus may be on opposite sides of the moral argument.

Consider a scenario where you discover an injured person by the side of the road. You may decide to help them, and the outcome would therefore be beneficial to the person.

However this result can be achieved via two Maxim's:

"Help those in need", or "Help those in need and you shall be rewarded"

Arguably the second one is a less moral version of the first, since it predisposes personal gain from what is, at least outwardly, an apparently self-less act. Thus the action is not entirely driven by a sense of duty.

Kant sets out his version of categorical imperatives, or rules if you will, that suggest a framework on which to hang judgment of our actions in the moral sense, chief amongst them being:

"Treat other people as ends in themselves, never as means to an end" 

Which roughly fits with a more commonly heard christian tradition ethic in todays language of:

"Do unto others as you have them do to you"

The main criticism of Kant's theory is that it can of course be demonstrated to be used with very immoral maxims, and in some ways doesn't really tell us what we should do, just how to judge what we might. There are also moral dilemma's where some immoral acts based on breaking a maxim might lead to a moral outcome. For example, not telling a gunman where his target is, if you actually do know that information. This goes against "You should always tell the truth" but may in effect save someones life. "The lesser of two evils..." so to speak. 

Consequentialist theory

This problem with Kant's view of morality brings us nicely onto the next ethical model. That of consequence. Consequentialism, as the name implies, looks at the outcomes of actions to determine the nature of whether that action is moral or not. The best known of these is utilitarianism. The underpinning principle of good moral action in this case is defined as "that which brings the greatest good to the greatest number of people"

It is a system that very broadly encompasses much of the legal systems of the western world. Since rule based utilitarianism could be said to be a version of "law" by which people live their lives.

However. As has been discussed in much of my recent writings, pure application of this method does lead to under representation of the minority groups of society, Since by virtue of their being in the minority they will always be disadvantaged in terms of that defining principle. Plus, there is the ever present question of where does one draw the line's when considering actions that are good for one group but evidently bad or questionable for another.

One way to address this is to apply Negative utilitarianism. Basing ones actions on the outcome that produces the least amount of suffering rather than the greatest amount of a universal good, (happiness)

Both of these have limitations, and still bring up situational moral dilemmas. Also there are problems of weighing one action against another and the possible justification of immoral actions based on the idea of the greater good. (For example, how many times has that argument been used as a reason for going to war?)

Virtue based theory.

Rising from a study of Aristotle's Nicomachean ethics, Virtue theorists considered the question,

"How should one live their life?

The answer was to cultivate the virtues, and thus "flourish", leading a successful and prosperous life. This you might think is very similar to the Kantian ethics version of a Maxim, which it is, but with one critical difference. Virtue theorists included the emotional aspect of human intention. 

Bringing emotion into a central role allowed discussion of things like compassion, generosity, and charity. It raised the issue of why we might act to benefit our fellow humans from one of mere duty to one of empathy, and being able to appreciate the consequences of their situation through a form of kin ship with them. 

It encourages one to look for the similarities between different peoples, actions, viewpoints etc, and base ones actions from those observations.

The criticism of virtue based theory is simply, "what is to be classed as a virtue?" There is still much discussion around what to include in a list of virtues, since "That which allows one to flourish" is open to interpretation. 

Additionally people change, their inherent tendencies altering over time with experience. Thus one might start off with the virtue of generosity, but having been conned in the  past by an immoral individual, reassess that view in later life. There is also the consideration of "Human Nature" and arguments as to what that is, or if it exists. 

These are three of the major ethical theories that exist. There are others, and this page here gives a very brief breakdown of each, including those discussed here. 

One slightly confusing thing however, that some of you might have noticed, is that in all of the above  there still isn't a clear definitional of what is "right" or "wrong" in the moral context. 

To answer that it is necessary to study and theorise on the ethical theories. A field known a "Meta Ethics" 

And that we will leave till part 2. 

Sarah 



Saturday, 18 March 2017

The Concept of God.. some thoughts.

Hello! Welcome to another Saturday morn' powered by the human mind and copious never ending cups of tea.

A little while ago I got myself a copy of  Nigel Warburtons book "the basics of philosophy", and did a wee blog saying that I planned on reading each chapter/section and then jotting down my thoughts on the arguments and concepts within.

See here

The first of these that Nigel explores in the book is the question "Does God exist?" OK, for some to even ask this is a big step, however it is a problem thats has kept religious philosophers busy for centuries and is at the very heart of religious teachings.

Some key concepts.

Theists, is a term used to describe those who believe in a classical vision of God as singular being, a person if you will, who is supremely benevolent, omnipresent and all powerful.

Atheists as I'm sure you're all aware do not believe this version of God to be real, they do not believe in this God.

Agnostics reserve judgement, preferring to wait it out a little on the fence.

There's little point in me re-writing Nigel's book here since he has done a much better job of it than I could ever hope to do, so I will limit myself to a brief mention of the arguments pertaining to the existence (or otherwise) of the theists God

The Design argument - such complex beings as humans must have been designed by a supreme  intelligence.

The fine tuning argument - The idea that the chances of us humans existing are so small that it must have been pre ordained by a God ala the design argument.

The first cause argument - Everything has a cause, but what is the first  cause? proponents of this argument suggest the first cause is God. but then what caused God?

The Ontological argument - God exists simply as a result of his definition as an all powerful omnipresent being.

Ok, so in a slight shift of Focus, what struck me in reading the book is that it discusses only one possible version of God, namely the one the theists ascribe to, and the judo-christian view of a  singular entity. There are differing religions in the world, thus many people have come up with differing views of this thing called God. So in that vein I've been exploring the question

"What is God?"

First of all I think its' fair to say that God is or has a concept. This concept varies dependent on the teaching to which you ascribe, but non the less, God, as a "supreme power" and "the creator" is pretty much a  universal view. That this is true does not prove that God does/doesn't exist, merely that our knowledge of God is shaped by the world in which we inhabit, and that we humans have some idea or concept of "God" be that the theists version or other variants. "God" and the "Concept of God" are thus related but different things.

Theists ascribe two other virtues to this supreme being. "All knowing" and "All good" but this is  based on the concept of God being sentient, a person if you will. So I'm going to leave those aside for now. 

The ontological argument for existence of God suggest that God exists simply as a result of being an all powerful, all knowing God. Its a flawed argument in that as Nigel suggests , existence is not a property per see. Rather It is a precondition of having any properties at all. To use the example in the book, being unmarried is an essential property of being a bachelor, but saying bachelors exist is not conferring any further properties on the definition of bachelor. 

However. Lets turn the ontological argument on it's head. We humans exist. So then what are humans? We are a self aware species with knowledge of the past coupled with an ability to envisage the future as we might like it, based on this past experience. ("imagination" and "learning" if you will) As a result we've built things called societies.

This then means the definition of "bachelor" and its inherent properties must exist inside a societal framework and awareness, one must know what a "bachelor" is in the wider context for the term to have any meaning. So, then could the concept of God exist simply because we humans are aware of ourselves? 

Consider the old saying:

"If a tree falls in the forest and no one hears it does it still make a noise"
and alter it to:

"If a tree falls in the forest and no one is aware of it's falling did it still fall? 

In the first saying the answer depends on the definition of "noise". We and many animals perceive noise through the vibration of air on an ear drum. thus if theres no ear drum then the vibration goes unheard. But that which would give rise to noise in the presence of an ear drum still exists. (rather like sending a radio signal out to an absent receiver) 

However in the second we "could" sumise it fell, since the tree can be proved to be on the ground, but as no one saw it fall we cannot prove how it got there. A little like the schrodingers cat conundrum. Since we are self aware and have experience based on what is "likely" to have occurred we come up with a list of scenarios and pick the most appealing. In this case being that it probably did fall to it's current position, for how else could it have gotten there?

Its this last bit, "how else could it have gotten there?" that brings us back to God. The design argument is a reflection of this question. We are so complex, so indescribably wondrous as beings in the frankly ridiculously improbable world that is Earth in the vastness of the universe, that we must have been dreamt up by an all powerful being who kinda looks like us but knows way more. But the design argument has its well documented flaws, and a long time influence on my scientific thinking Dr Richard Dawkins has covered this at length so for me it doesn't quite cut it. 

In indulging this train of thought as I read the book I found myself drawn to what is known as "non realism". An idea that God exists simply as an aspirational concept of humanities' better and more praise worthy traits, which I found to be in essence a reversal of the cause and effect of the design argument. We do not exist because God made us. Rather God "exists" or least the concept does, in some sense because we became aware of the concept of God. 

However. 

What caused this awareness? The first cause argument states that everything is a result of something else. You kick a football, it moves, you cut your hair, it gets shorter, You touch water, you get wet, Causality is a thing that I've been involved with from a scientific viewpoint over many years, first with cellular physiology, then latterly health care diagnostics, and now management theory. Why something occurred and what pre condition(s) caused its coming about is a question that keeps many minds busy. As for the cause of our self awareness? The truth is, other than suposed evolutionary pressures, and speculation, we simply don't know. 

If you'll indulge me in a purely speculative moment, mythology often has its roots in long forgotten experiences. It's not wholly outside the bounds of credibility to suggest that enduring myths of other worldly beings might have something to do with this thousands of years ago. We humans tells stories of all sorts of weird and wonderful things, from superman, to mutant super heroes, giant extra terrestrial robots and stuff like lord of the rings or the avengers. Those are of course modern examples but their lineage is way back round camp fires, eons before 4k telly's were "a thing' and "a thing" was considered an expression. An admittedly "far fetched" thought is that our vision of God as a person may stem from long lost knowledge of some vastly powerful being on earth of unknown origin that has then become legend, myth and eventually ..religion. But, moving away from self indulgent conjecture, its fair to say enduring stories whatever their inception, may well have played a part in how humans evolved the theist concept of God, or even multiple gods as the greeks did.

My point is that somewhere back in our lost evolutionary past whilst sitting round that camp fire re-telling stores of monsters battled or daring feats of bravery we asked a simple yet profound question, 

"Where did we come from?"

It is worth mentioning here that "Evolutionary" might predispose some to think I do not believe in God since the world was created in 7 days. I've always been in the camp of the genesis story being metaphorical, and the evolutionary process being akin to the paint brush not the painter. Way back in 5th year during my school RE  (year 11 for younger readers) I coined the thought that evolution is the "how" and God, whatever that might be is perhaps the  "why" 

Another point that the first cause argument brought into focus for me is the question of God's  relationship with Time. If God is to be considered the first cause then he was arround before the  beginning of what we commonly call time. Usually thought of as the big bang. Could this mean God is timeless, ever present? 

It's here that I began to form the basis of an opinion, or position on the issue of God, since a few threads seemed to be coalescing in my mind. 

  • Humans are self aware. We remember, and question. 
  • God was was supposedly there at the beginning (big bang)
  • Awareness of something does not prove or disprove its existence. 
  • Ignorance or unknowingness does not prove/disprove existence.


So. millennia ago its possible that somehow we humans became aware of Time, mortality, and our species' existence in a way, and on a level that we do not yet see in other primates. (Although by all accounts evolution is still occurring and new things being discovered) Around this point we as a species also became aware of the questions "why are we here?" and "how did we get we here?"

Our respective cultures and story telling ability thus led to accounts, some very likely born of factual events, that have been passed down through the centuries. These stores are thus interpreted and examined, re written and disseminated, ultimately becoming what we know today as "religions" 

Could "Time" perhaps then be said to start for the human race at this point of awareness, rather than the "big bang" and thus so begins our evolutionary tale of the knowledge of the concept of self, species, and thus of God. (The beginnings of known real  time, documented human history?) 

But hang on, what about those trees in the forest? Stephen Hawking has done brilliant job of discussing time as we know it here...


In the article Professor Hawking describes the period before the big bang as having no observational consequence, thus from the POV of physics this can be left out of the equation. The big bang is the beginning (for us) of observable time, observable change. But we know God isn't supposed to be constrained by mere things like physics, other wise that would disprove the all powerful angle and much like that tree in the forest, observation does not prove or disprove existence, Thus one can theorise that a measure of something akin to time, perhaps infinite, existed in a unobserved way before the big bang. 

It is this that has lead me to an oddly simple thought. Could the concept of God be the result of human knowledge of Time itself? Moreover Could God actually Be Time? After all "old father time" is a well known expression?  It dates back to greek mythology "times". 

I tried to test this idea by breaking it. 

It's not unreasonable to theorise that the big bang we humans know as the start of our observable time could well have been the end of something else, unknown and now unknowable, thus the law of unending causality would be satisfied. The mechanism for the continuation of "another time" back before the big bang is simply that there are unobserved trees falling in a unknown forest, due to unknown forces and the passage of "their" time. 

But what of the things I've mentioned at the beginning?, of God being "all knowing" and "all good"?  Well God as Time would certainly "see all" since for anything to exist in our physical world post big  bang it must have, or have had, a greater than Zero time integer. And in "another time" before the big bang one can theorise that though different, and unknowable, this may have been true, since "our time" can exist independently of any observed or actual change and in the absence of the awareness of time  (consider a box of space vacuum, the fact it has "nothing" in it does not suddenly halt time. or perhaps an empty street at night, time still passes.) It's therefore not unreasonable to carry this premise backwards to before the big bang. 

However God as Time cannot be "all good" as it fails the test of the "problems of evil". Since some evil things happen with the passage of time. Probably due to "free will" in the case of humans and "random causality" in the case of natural disaster, time itself could be said to be complicit. 

But this does not in and of itself break the theory, since the premise of God as Good is tenant of the theists definition of God and not that of God as Time. 

If one accepts this definition of God as Time, it has similar ramifications to the non realism argument, indeed it could be said to be a version of it:
  • Religion becomes merely a consequence of human self awareness, and societal pressure. 
  • Religious morality can no longer be consider divine wisdom since the words of the various religious texts are reduced to merely those of men observing the world as they see it, regardless of how profound and wise they may be. 
  • Good and Evil become action based and not based upon the promise of a physical Heaven or  hell. 
  • God as Time makes no comment on the possibility of life after death. 


The third of these, the idea of a heaven or hell and resurrection/damnation has never sat well with me. Not because I have issue with the concepts, but rather the religious mechanism by which one enters either place. Moral actions, or "good" actions should be based on the intent to do good, rather than the intent to profit by the doing of good. Thus the idea of accessing heaven though a life of devotion is in my view too close to the gambler argument of Pascals wager. (the idea that its better to hedge your bets and believe in the theists God rather than be proved wrong and spend an eternity in hell.) 

Another place where "God as Time" and the traditional theist view diverge is this idea of "God" being the supreme moral authority. Nigel goes into the arguments surrounding God and morality much deeper than I have here, since I've barely touched them, so if you want to look at those grab a copy of his book, its well worth taking "the time" to read. (yeah its a bad pun, but I couldn't resist.) Handily though the next chapter in Nigel's book is all about Right and Wrong. So perhaps after looking at and writing about it i'll revisit this "loose thread" regarding God in a future article.

In conclusion, and I admit somewhat annoyingly, what really puzzles me is the premise I came up with all those years back in school. God as the "why" and evolution as the "how." God as Time starts to break a little here since Time, like evolution could be argued to be a mechanism for change.
Occasionally it's a driver but sometimes just a facilitator. Thus one can suggest that Time is merely another tool of the theist's concept of God and that God exists in an entirely different way. The only way to answer this is to either accept there is no why, thus Time is just Time therefore God doesn't exist, or that God is something else, separate from time, and that brings us right back to square one...

What is God?

And to answer that we need to figure out if God actually exists.....

;-) 

Have a great weekend, a lovely "Time", and may the  "God(s)" smile upon your endeavours. 

till next time 

Sarah